also:
ST: Presidential Hopeful Wiranto Fires First Salvo; and AFR Perspective:
The Elections That Could Change the Global Game [incl: Indonesia]
excerpt from
AFR Perspective: Australia's relations with Indonesia are not bad
... ...but they are awkward. This partly stems from the Bali bombing.
Another issue blamed for the strain is East Timor, but Garnaut (architect
of the Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation idea) says this is more
because of the
way we have presented our involvement in East Timor than the involvement
itself.
Australian
Financial Review
Saturday, January 17, 2004
Wiranto
Poses Real Challenge to Megawati
By Andrew Burrell
Jakarta - Sharing
lunch with an indicted war criminal accused of overseeing the slaughter
of 1500 people is hardly an everyday experience. Neither is it as
difficult as it might seem.
Indonesia's
smiling former armed forces chief Wiranto chomped on roasted chicken
and sipped iced water, while chatting pleasantly, even humbly, with
a group of Jakarta's foreign journalists on Thursday.
The charismatic
56-year-old, more famous in Indonesia for singing soppy love songs
than for his alleged human rights violations in East Timor, is a
man on the hustings. The lunch date was part of an attempted image
makeover that may help deliver him the presidency at elections this
year, when 145million Indonesians will vote directly for their head
of state for the first time.
Such a mission
by a man so closely associated with the authoritarian Soeharto regime
would have been unthinkable a few years ago. But in 2004, with the
spirit of reformasi waning and nostalgia for Soeharto surging, a
Wiranto presidency has become realistic.
After four
years in the political wilderness, Wiranto is back on the front
pages of Indonesia's vibrant press, running an energetic campaign
that involves criss-crossing the massive archipelago in a chartered
plane.
The retired
four-star general is, after all, a good story. Unlike some others,
he doesn't shy away from answering claims about the excesses committed
during his period in power. A new self-penned book, Witness in the
Storm:
Truth Revealed by Wiranto, addresses many of the allegations head-on
(albeit with
stony denials of responsibility) and has been translated into English.
Rumours abound
of how his campaign is funded by Soeharto family money or the military,
or that Wiranto has formed alliances with potential running mates.
His popularity
is aided by him singing on the campaign trail, often songs from
an album of ballads he released a couple of years ago.
Indonesian
politics is volatile and unpredictable, but opinion polls give Wiranto
a real chance of toppling the frontrunner, President Megawati Soekarnoputri.
His revival
has also coincided with a change in fortunes for Indonesia's military,
which was sidelined in disgrace after the events of 1998 but which
has been able to regain much of its influence under Megawati, despite
losing its
right to seats in parliament.
Polls indicate
that another retired general, chief security minister Susilo Bambang
Yudhoyono, is another main contender for the top job - if he decides
to run.
"The president
of Indonesia should definitely come from the military," says
Cik Bujang, a businessman in central Jakarta. "And I think
Wiranto is the best candidate to be president because his track
record in the military is good and clean."
The elections
will likely be held in two stages: a first round on July5 and, assuming
no single candidate wins more than 50 per cent of the vote, a final
run-off between the top two names on September 20.
If Wiranto
does become president, he will face some immediate hurdles. Chief
among them is a distinct lack of support, even a sense of revulsion,
among many Western countries, including Australia and the United
States, for his candidacy. Last year, United Nations-funded prosecutors
in East Timor indicted Wiranto on charges of crimes against humanity,
claiming he bore ultimate
command responsibility for the military-backed slaughter and destruction
during Indonesia's bloody withdrawal from its breakaway province
in 1999.
Indonesia has
refused to extradite any military leaders over the carnage, but
East Timor's chief prosecutor insists he is close to obtaining an
Interpol warrant for Wiranto, which could lead to his arrest if
he travels abroad. Wiranto denies such a warrant would affect his
ability to be president, or to interact with other countries.
The human rights
claims are unlikely to become a domestic issue in the campaign,
according to a think tank, the International Crisis Group. For most
Indonesians, the East Timor bloodshed is an issue best forgotten.
"Indeed, Wiranto
would probably be more vulnerable electorally to charges of having
failed to prevent the loss of East Timor," the ICG says. A
former trusted aide of Wiranto, former general Kiki Syahnakie, says
his old colleague is popular because he
has the proven ability to manage a crisis. He, too, is sure that
most voters will ignore the human rights claims.
"You have
to understand this is the way of thinking among the middle and lower
classes," says Syahnakie, who was indicted for crimes against
humanity by East Timor's prosecutors. "Those kinds of sensitivities
about the human rights
abuses only develop among the upper, educated class."
Nor is there
much risk that most voters would worry about a return, after only
six years, to authoritarianism or militarism under a Wiranto presidency,
analysts say. According to military strategist Agus Wijoyo, Wiranto
has
been able to successfully sell himself as a proponent of democracy
because he supported the transition from Soeharto to his successor,
BJ Habibie, in 1998 when he had the clear opportunity to seize power
himself.
Unsurprisingly,
Wiranto is campaigning in the provinces on a law-and-order platform
in an attempt to capitalise on the rising nostalgia, especially
at village level, for the sense of security and stability during
Soeharto's rule.
He is also
running hard on economic recovery, telling the packed lunchtime
audience that included foreign diplomats and businesspeople this
week that he would address Indonesia's weak legal system and burgeoning
corruption -
although he failed to provide any details of practical measures.
He also talks
about the struggle of the Indonesian people since the economic crisis
hit in 1997. As about half of Indonesia's population lives on less
than $US2 ($2.60) a day, any promise to again provide the cheap
rice that was
common in the Soeharto era is bound to be a vote-winner.
Wiranto depicts
himself as a man of peace, taking credit for stopping the bloodshed
in Aceh in the late 1990s and promising to end the present offensive
in the troubled province if he were elected president, a plan that
will hardly
make him popular with Indonesia's crop of military leaders.
He says the
allegations of human rights abuses in East Timor were exaggerated
and never proved by a court. He insists he ensured the lead-up to
the independence ballot in 1999 was peaceful and the violence that
erupted later was beyond his control.
He also paints
himself as a patriotic man who has been called back to duty by his
nation, compelled to return to the political sphere after once mulling
a post-military career as a corn farmer.
Born in Yogyakarta
on April 4, 1947, Wiranto began his military career soon after graduating
from the National Military Academy in 1968. According to Kevin O'Rourke's
book, Reformasi, Wiranto whiled away the first half of his career
in mundane army jobs, including a 12-year stint in a sleepy outpost
in North Sulawesi.
By 1980, after
contemplating early retirement to become a county magistrate, he
had managed to secure a position in the army's strategic reserve,
after which he was transferred to Jakarta.
Then followed
a meteoric rise through the ranks, under Soeharto's close supervision.
By 1989, Wiranto had been made personal adjutant to the president,
one of the military's most coveted jobs. In 1995, he was made commander
of the
Jakarta garrison, and in the following year elevated to commander
of Kostrad, the army's main combat force. In June 1997, he was made
a four-star general and sworn in as army chief-of-staff, and the
word in military circles was that
Soeharto was grooming his protege to be his eventual successor.
The following
year, with unrest mounting against the regime, Soeharto elevated
Wiranto to minister of defence and armed forces chief - the first
time since the 1970s that one man had held the two jobs at the same
time.
But Wiranto's
period in these roles coincided with some of Indonesia's most publicised
recent abuses, such as the Trisakti and Semanggi shootings in Jakarta,
clashes with police in Maluku and, most notoriously, the East Timor
scorched-earth campaign.
Wiranto was
sacked in January 2000 by president Abdurrahman Wahid.
Before a rejuvenated
Wiranto can take on Megawati this year, he must first claim the
prized nomination of the Golkar party, the election vehicle that
kept Soeharto in power for 32 years.This
will be no simple task. Wiranto faces his toughest opposition from
Golkar's powerful chairman Akbar Tandjung, a wily politician who
has been convicted of corruption but is awaiting an appeal verdict,
rumoured to be handed down soon.
A successful
appeal would set up an intriguing clash with Wiranto, but a loss
would end Tandjung's political career and pave the way for Wiranto.
Behind these
frontrunners are two wealthy businessmen: media magnate Surya Paloh,
who owns the Metro TV station and the Media Indonesia newspaper,
and the chairman of the chamber of commerce, Aburizal Bakrie.
Rounding out
the Golkar field are three nominees with little chance: cabinet
minister Jusuf Kalla, Soeharto's former son-in-law Prabowo Subianto,
and the Sultan of Yogyakarta, who is popular in Central Java but
will strugglelsewhere.
Wiranto has
so far garnered most of his support from Golkar's local branches.
As part of a party convention last year to choose its candidates,
Wiranto won 124 districts, followed by Tandjung with 91 and Paloh
with 64.
The make-up
of the presidential race will hinge on the results of the April
5 legislative elections. If Golkar outpolls Megawati's Indonesian
Democratic Party of Struggle (PDIP), as most analysts expect, the
two big parties will likely field separate candidates. Megawati
is already confirmed as her party's nominee.
If the PDIP
finishes first, Golkar's party bosses may decide to settle for the
vice-presidency on a potentially unbeatable joint ticket with PDIP,
the only other major secular-nationalist party.
Whatever the
outcome, such decisions will have to be finalised by late April
or early May.
A typically
uncompromising Wiranto says he would never accept the vice-presidency.
"An old
soldier never dies," he smiles, before spouting another favourite
motto that seems to suit Indonesia's evolving democracy in 2004.
"Just let the people vote."
-----------------------------
The Straits
Times
Saturday, January 17, 2004
Presidential
Hopeful Wiranto Fires First Salvo
By Robert Go
JAKARTA - Indonesia's
reform initiatives have failed and the country needs a strong leader
'who can do better', said retired General Wiranto.
The Suharto-era
armed forces commander has become a serious contender for presidential
elections later this year.
During an unprecedented
two-hour luncheon talk attended by foreign journalists and diplomats
on Thursday, he said he was a champion of democracy who has heard
a 'call of duty' to go for the top job, as there is 'a lack of leadership
in the country'.
These remarks
represented Gen Wiranto's first public salvoes against President
Megawati Sukarnoputri and the reform-era government.
Said the one-time
aide-de-camp to former strongman Suharto: 'If we want to be honest,
the process of reform, which has been in place for the past five
years, has not actually brought about significant change.'
He also blamed
the slowness of Indonesia's economic recovery on the government
in power, saying: 'A weak and visionless leader will never be
able to
accelerate the process of restoring stability and national economy.'
On Indonesia's
serious problems - poverty, rising unemployment, separatism, sectarian
conflicts and terrorism - he argued that the people 'deserve a government
that is much better than what is in place'.
Although he
is 'optimistic' about his chances, he faces a first challenge from
rivals within the political party of his choice, Suharto's Golkar
party.
Golkar was
discredited after Suharto's downfall in 1998, but its strong regional
network has facilitated a rejuvenation during the last five years.
It has floated
at least seven potential presidential candidates, including party
leader and Parliamentary Speaker Akbar Tandjung, who maintains a
strong support network despite a graft conviction.
Analysts said
Golkar could increase its share of parliamentary seats in April's
legislative elections, perhaps at the expense of Ms Megawati's PDI-P
party.
Gen Wiranto
is also dodging allegations of human rights abuses related to massacres
that took place around East Timor's separation from Indonesia in
1999. United Nations prosecutors have issued an indictment for him.
He attempted
to address his track record, saying: 'A commander in chief should
not always be held accountable for what military personnel have
done.'
He drew a comparison
to massacres by American forces during the Vietnam War, and pointed
out that the US commander was not accused of human rights violations.
|